Commitment isn't what it used to be...
Anyone familiar with weddings knows the drill: for richer or poorer, in sickness and in health, until death do us part. But if New Jersey author and wedding expert Sharon Naylor has analyzed the current direction of marriage correctly, that phrase may soon pass from modern weddings faster than it has from modern marriages.
In her book, Your Special Wedding Vows, Naylor tells us that the whole notion of sticking around until someone dies has increasingly become passé. In fact, the entire notion of having to live up to that commitment causes nothing but grief and mental anguish, Naylor claimed to Fox News last week.
"When people get divorced, they mourn the fact that they said 'til death do us part'--you didn't keep your word in church (if they had a church wedding). Some people are in therapy because they promised 'til death do us part.'"
So what does Naylor propose for modern vows and modern marriages? Something a little less judgmental, non-binding. Here are a few suggestions for the blushing bride and her groom to consider when tying the ever-more-slippery knot:
Noble: "For as long as our marriage may serve the greater good."
Poetic: "For as long as our love shall last."
Prosaic: "For as long as we continue to love each other."
Clock watchers: "Until our time together is over."
Notice how all of the above depend on completely subjective judgments, despite a desired escape from the judgment of failure when vowing to stay married until death. These judgments don't depend on a mutually agreed finality, either; they all provide plenty of leeway for one partner to declare that the meter has run out. In fact, it takes the partnership out of marriage altogether and replaces it with a temporary commingling of shared transient interests, implicitly declaring that these interests will at some point diverge. None of them address children, families, or communities; they completely center on the fleeting gratification of the two people at the altar.
It takes a commitment to keep working at the relationship when it no longer feels fun or exciting, and it takes discipline to keep outside distractions from reducing the will to perform that hard work. Instead of recognizing commitment as the essential ingredient of marriage, however, these new trends specifically avoid the entire idea of commitment and effort.
It's no coincidence that marriage continues to struggle as a social structure in an age that devalues commitment and looks for exit strategies regardless of the endeavor.
It may sound like a conservative's marriage manifesto: Pick a partner with a similar background, don't shack up without an engagement ring and stick with even a lifeless marriage for your kids' sake.
Although surviving the chaos of Iraq, thousands of soldiers have become casualties of a fight they were poorly trained for: keeping control of their family lives during the separation of war. Men and women who feel lucky that their units suffered few fatalities say they can name dozens who returned home to empty houses, squandered bank accounts, divorce papers and restraining orders.
As I watch the posts coming into our forums,
A new study from Duke and the University Of Chicago looked at the long-term health consequences of people who are married, divorced, widowed, remarried, and single.
Just Married: What Might Surprise You about the First Few Years
Adventures in Holy Matrimony: For Better or the Absolute Worst

